Escape from the phantom of the PDF

14 November 2024

Aquatint showing a graveyard scene in front of a church. At the center is a man in armour with a distressed expression on his face. To his left is a skeleton, and to his right a ghost. — A man in armour is confronted by a ghost and a skeleton. Aquatint. Wellcome Collection, Public Domain.

In a recent blog post, colleagues at the National Digital Preservation Services in Finland addressed an issue with PDF files that contain strings with octal escape sequences. These are not parsed correctly by JHOVE, and the resulting parse errors ultimately lead to (seemingly unrelated) validation errors. The authors argue that octal escape sequences present a preservation risk, as they may confuse other software besides JHOVE. Since this claim is not backed up by any evidence, here I put this to the test using 8 different PDF processing tools and libraries.

JPEG quality estimation using simple least squares matching of quantization tables

30 October 2024

Photograph of faded sign on building front showing the word 'Quality'. — Adapted from Quality Coal by Greenville Daily Photo. Used under CC0 1.0. license.

In my previous post I addressed several problems I ran into when I tried to estimate the “last saved” quality level of JPEG images. It described some experiments based on ImageMagick’s quality heuristic, which led to a Python implementation of a modified version of the heuristic that improves the behaviour for images with a quality of 50% or less.

I still wasn’t entirely happy with this solution. This was partially because ImageMagick’s heuristic uses aggregated coefficients of the image’s quantization tables, which makes it potentially vulnerable to collisions. Another concern was, that the reasoning behind certain details of ImageMagick’s heuristic seems rather opaque (at least to me!).

In this post I explore a different approach to JPEG quality estimation, which is based on a straightforward comparison with “standard” JPEG quantization tables using least squares matching. I also propose a measure that characterizes how similar an image’s quantization tables are to its closest “standard” tables. This could be useful as a measure of confidence in the quality estimate. I present some tests where I compare the results of the least squares matching method with those of the ImageMagick heuristics. I also discuss the results of a simple sensitivity analysis.

JPEG quality estimation: experiments with a modified ImageMagick heuristic

23 October 2024

Photograph of golden retriever dog Bailey sitting at a desk in front of a laptop, bashing her paws away at the laptop's keyboard while wearing a necktie. — Bailey AKA the "I have no idea what I'm doing" dog. License unknown.

In this post I explore some of the challenges I ran into while trying to estimate the quality level of JPEG images. By quality level I mean the percentage (1-100) that expresses the lossiness that was applied by the encoder at the last “save” operation. Here, a value of 1 results in very aggressive compression with a lot of information loss (and thus a very low quality), whereas at 100 almost no information loss occurs at all¹.

More specifically, I focus on problems with ImageMagick’s JPEG quality heuristic, which become particularly apparent when applied to low quality images. I also propose a simple tentative solution, that applies some small changes to ImageMagick’s heuristic.

Multi-image TIFFs, subfiles and image file directories

11 March 2024

Photograph that shows a hammer that is used to smash a screw into a piece of wood. On the left is a nail that is partially pushed into the same piece of wood, with an adjustable wrench immediately next to it. — "Confused, muddled, illogical". Used under Pixabay License.

The KB has been using JP2 (JPEG 2000 Part 1) as the primary file format for its mass-digitisation activities for over 15 years now. Nevertheless, we still use uncompressed TIFF for a few collections. At the moment there’s an ongoing discussion about whether we should migrate those to JP2 as well at some point to save storage costs. Last week I ran a small test on a selection of TIFFs from those collections. I first converted them to JP2, and then verified whether no information got lost during the conversion. This resulted in some unexpected surprises, which turned out to be caused by the presence of thumbnail images in some of the source TIFFs. This post discusses the impact of having multiple images indide a TIFF on preservation workflows, and also provides some suggestions on how to identify such files.

VeraPDF parse status as a proxy for PDF rendering: experiments with the Synthetic PDF Testset

29 June 2023

Vintage lithograph circus poster that shows a circus ring. In the front is a woman in a red dress, standing on horseback. Behind her there are more horses, with a variety of circus artists, including acrobats and jugglers, performing on horseback as well. In the background acrobats are walking on a tightrope. — "The Barnum & Bailey greatest show on earth". Used under CC BY-BY 2.0, via Boston Public Library.

Last month I wrote this post, which addresses the use of JHOVE and VeraPDF for identifying preservation risks in PDF files. In the concluding section I suggested that VeraPDF’s parse status might be used as a rough “validity proxy” to identify malformed PDFs. But does VeraPDF’s parse status actually have any predictive value for rendering? And how does this compare to what JHOVE tells us? This post is a first attempt at answering these questions, using data from the Synthetic PDF Testset for File Format Validation by Lindlar, Tunnat and Wilson.

« Newer 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 Older »

Search

Tags

Archive

November

October

March

June

May

March

February

January

November

June

April

March

September

February

September

June

April

March

February

September

April

March

January

July

April

July

June

April

January

December

April

March

December

November

October

July

April

March

January

December

November

October

September

August

January

October

September

August

July

May

April

January

December

September

August

July

June

April

January

December

September

July

June

December

Issues

Social

Feeds